I have been trying to validate my course, but faced an interesting situation. I am building a course for experimental scientists. However, many told me that they prefer reading by themselves than watching a video of someone programming. And, I do agree with them. It is much quicker to skim through the things you don't care about.
Now, a text-based course in my mind means writing a book. Which, in turn, means lower perceived value, and higher expected production value. So, I wonder if you ever crossed any text-based course, how did you feel about it? Was it helpful? What was the pedagogical approach?
Hey!
I've been developing text-based courses in my project: www.nocodehackers.es and people seem to love them when they need to follow steps or a proccess.
The main consensus is that for complex topics or things that require some level of a deeper explanation, video is better, but that text helps them to follow steps, and have a place to return to without skimming trough the video.
Hope it helps!
I liked your website. Will sign up to the free course to see what you are talking about. I've seen other people doing something similar to what you describe, video followed by succint text, so it is easy to go back without re-watching everything.
Text based courses are hard to do.
I spend more than 4 years seeing courses and reading books of different topics, from that experience I can tell you:
I have done more video courses than books, why? for me it's because they are easy for your brain, you have visual, sound and text cues.
Nowadays video courses include a workbook, initially I thought they were not usefully but then I started to see better and better ones, which helped me to remember what I saw in previous chapters.
Text-based course are hard to follow because of the lack of sound and visual cues, but that is not a problem if you are willing to have an appropriate time designing your content well, let me give you some examples:
Courses
Brilliant: For me, the best platform with written courses and even better the best science courses I saw as a beginner
RefactoringUI: A nice written book that really delivers value on each image and word
Blogs
https://ciechanow.ski/lights-and-shadows
https://github.com/a327ex/blog/issues/30
http://www.r2d3.us/visual-intro-to-machine-learning-part-1/
https://www.lightnote.co/
Of course, I don't have any experience creating content, so I say all of this from my consumer experience
I wrote some Docker course, text based, sold 20-30 copies... 20 pages length, it doesn't have to be a book.
For what it’s worth: I appreciate the option for both. I recently purchased a course and found myself flipping between the PDFs and the video.
What was the course about? To have an idea of whether it is in the same realm or not.
Hi Aquiles,
If I understand correctly, you might want to check Next.js I think its one of the best I have seen based on UI and even the thorough walk-thru (I'm fairly new to programming only a year old, so there might be something else better). So check it out for inspiration. And might be a better way than thinking about making a book as you have mentioned, plus maybe you can even split it into a weekly lesson to not have pressure to need to finish the course before you ship it.
Also, you can check Dan Abramov's Just JavaScript which is simple and unique! I have learned many things from his simple way of explaining the mental model of how JavaScript works and removing any complexity.
Another example is The Odin Project but I still think Next.js is better.
Mozilla's is famous also but I think its a bit dry.
But in general I think having a text based course is useful.
And all the best on this new course you're working on!
Thanks for the links!
Yeah, Mozilla is great as a quick reference but not to get started on them. Next.js seems very sleek. I'll check the other as soon as I have time
Personally I also prefer text. Video is super slow and often full of irrelevant stuff that I want to skip. I think the key to a text based course is to make it bite-sized and make it possible to complete each part. This mild gamification works like chapters in a book, and makes you keep thinking "I can complete just one more part" - leading to much higher completion rates.
I also prefer text over video except if it is for a visual guide (for example, a course on how to use Photoshop is inherently visual, while how to program is inherently written).
Do you have any examples to point me to in order to see how people have achieved what you suggest?
This comment was deleted 6 years ago
Well, this is a very biased comment, and does not answer any of my questions.