Zero paid users. Here's what I'm doing to find the first ones.

I’ve been in this exact stage and it’s honestly the hardest part. Building feels productive, but distribution feels invisible at first. What helped me was talking directly to a few real users 1-on-1 instead of trying to reach everyone at once. Even 5–10 active users can teach more than 1,000 impressions. Zero paid users doesn’t mean zero value — it usually just means the right people haven’t seen it yet. Keep shipping and keep conversations going.

The 6 clicks from 2k subs is actually useful data - it tells you the email list isn't the right channel. Those subscribers signed up for food blog content, not SaaS products. Different intent entirely.

What I've seen work at zero-to-first-paid: find where people are actively complaining about the problem RIGHT NOW. Reddit threads asking "how do I stop wasting groceries" or "meal planning apps that actually work". Quora questions. Facebook groups for meal prep. Those people have raised their hand and said "I have this problem today".

PH and directories are visibility plays - they get you in front of people browsing, not people searching. First paid customers almost always come from finding people mid-frustration.

@JustinBuilds , replying to your last note about weak transition:

Totally get that feeling and you’re right, adding more text isn’t the fix here.

Looking at the page, the real gap isn’t clarity, it’s contrast.
Right before “How it works,” the reader still hasn’t been told why every other solution quietly fails.

Most meal planners break not because they’re bad ideas, but because they assume:
– your pantry stays updated
– your schedule is predictable
– you’ll re-enter context every day

A short bridge that calls that out can make “How it works” feel like the resolution, not the explanation.

For example, something along the lines of:
“Most meal planners work great… until real life happens.
They forget what’s in your fridge, reset every week, and slowly turn into another app you stop opening.”

That sets up your steps as why this one doesn’t fall apart, instead of just how it functions.

If you want, I’m happy to do a tighter pass just on that transition so the flow feels inevitable rather than informational.

Solid advice in the comments—narrowing down to one killer problem for a specific audience is gold. I'm in the same boat with my AI toolkit for indie hackers (FounderHub), bootstrapping as a dadypreneur (diapers by day, code by night). I overbuilt mine too, thinking "more features = more users," but crickets until I started cold DMing people venting about marketing overload on X and Reddit. Got my first feedback loop that way, which led to tweaks and a couple sign-ups.

For MealThinker, maybe target busy parents in Facebook groups complaining about dinner chaos—offer a quick, no-strings demo via DM. It's unscalable at first, but those convos build real trust. Hang in there, Justin; that first paid user feels like winning the lottery. DM me if you want to swap war stories! 🚀

Been through this exact phase with a dev tool I'm working on. The hardest lesson for me was realizing that "shipping" isn't the finish line — it's barely the starting gun.

One thing that shifted my thinking: instead of asking "how do I get users," I started asking "where are people already frustrated about this problem TODAY?" That reframe changed everything. Stopped broadcasting, started listening.

For meal planning specifically, I'd look at where people are already complaining about the problem in real-time — food waste threads, busy parent groups, fitness communities tracking macros. Those folks already feel the pain. They're not browsing Product Hunt looking for solutions, they're venting in niche communities.

The first 10 customers rarely come from launches. They come from being genuinely helpful in the right place at the right time. Keep going — the building was the warm-up.

Hey Justin — totally feel this. I’m in a similar stage with my own product, and getting from “built” to “paid users” really is a different beast.

One thing that helped me get my first paying customer was setting up a consistent social media posting system. I started sharing small updates, category explainers, and behind-the-scenes posts across a few platforms daily. No ads, no growth hacks — just steady visibility.

It took a little time, but that consistency slowly built awareness and eventually brought in the first customer without spending anything. Nothing explosive, but it broke the zero-customer barrier and created momentum.

Curious to see what works for you next — keep sharing the journey.

Your app feels like the kind of tool busy people who still care about eating well would want (if they didn’t care about healthy eating, they probably wouldn’t cook at all).
Have you tried finding early users in communities where health and meal planning already matter? Like fitness groups, nutrition forums, or busy parent groups (especially mothers who often juggle meal planning). People in those areas are actively thinking about meals and might be more willing to try something that saves them time. There are also lots of social media influencers in these areas.

The shift from building to selling is exactly where the 'Inferno' begins. With a 0.3% CTR on your newsletter, the message isn't landing, not because the tool is bad, but because it’s likely too broad. For the first 10 paid users, stop yelling into the void of social media and go 'hand-to-hand.' Find a specific community (e.g., people on a specific keto diet or busy parents in a subreddit) and solve one urgent meal problem for them manually using your AI. General AI meal planners are a hard sell; a 'Time-saver for exhausted CrossFitters' is a product. Have you tried narrowing down your target persona to just one hyper-specific group?

I understand how you feel , I too am in this stage of my journey, it can be discouraging but keep at it I believe we would pull through

Hey Justin, this stage is painfully familiar.

What you’re describing usually isn’t a marketing failed problem, it’s a “the product does too many things for too many people” problem.

MealThinker is powerful, but right now it’s talking like a feature list when early users need to feel one sharp “this fixes my daily frustration” moment.

This is actually where I help founders the most.

narrow MealThinker down to one painfully clear promise for one type of user, translate what you built into a language that sounds like how users complain about the problem and turn your founder story and early experiments into content that pulls the right people in, instead of broadcasting to everyone

Usually that looks like:

1. tightening the homepage and onboarding around a single use case

2. shaping 2–3 core content angles that attract specific people already frustrated with meal planning

3. helping you get your first paying users through clarity and conversations, not ads or hacks

If you’re open to it, I’d love to take a quick look at your landing page or onboarding and give you a content strategist perspective on what might be blocking early conversion.

Either way, you’re not alone here.

The exact same thing happened to me. Building was the fun part; getting real users was a completely different story. What eventually helped me, after a long time, was truly going back to the problem and asking myself what problem I was actually solving.

Instead of just showing a product, I started talking to people who were experiencing that problem and trying to gather qualitative insights. That was my main takeaway from going through this.

Hey Justin! I'm literally in the exact same boat as you (well, I was until today). I just got my first 2 paying customers TODAY for my AI video generator, Keyvello - $38 MRR.

Here's what worked for me:

1. Launched on Product Hunt this morning (still live!)
2. Shared my journey authentically on Twitter/X - people love the "solo founder building in public" vibe
3. Posted demo videos in relevant Reddit communities (r/SideProject, r/startups) - but focused on being helpful, not salesy

The Product Hunt launch was key. I didn't expect conversions so fast, but having that social proof and the "live" urgency actually drove people to try it AND upgrade.

For your AI meal planner, have you tried AI-focused communities? There's huge interest in practical AI tools right now. Also, food/nutrition subreddits might love MealThinker if you frame it as solving a real problem (which it clearly does).

The building part really IS more fun than the marketing grind. But that first paying customer hit different - you'll get there! Keep pushing.

Going through this exact phase right now with a dev tool I just launched. The "yelling into the void" feeling is real.

What's clicking for me after reading through these comments + my own experiments: the platforms that feel scalable (launches, directories, social posts) rarely convert early. The things that feel unscalable (1:1 DMs, replying to people mid-frustration in niche communities) are where the first real signals come from.

I've also noticed that Reddit's spam filters are brutal for new accounts. Got auto-removed multiple times before I could even test whether the audience was right. Discord communities have been warmer — people actually reply and give feedback there.

The hardest mindset shift for me has been accepting that early traction isn't about reach. It's about finding 5-10 people who genuinely have the problem today and talking to them like humans, not leads.

Still figuring it out, but this thread is gold. Saving it.

Same stage here. Same pain.
I learned the hard way that Product Hunt + Hacker News don’t magically create users.
Distribution is way harder than building 😅
I liked to read the comments here to adapt our own strategy.

Same boat here with a few projects. What I've learned from talking to other bootstrapped founders: the first 10 customers almost never come from launches or directories. They come from hanging out where your users already are and being genuinely helpful.

For a meal planning app, I'd look at fitness/nutrition communities, busy parents groups, or people doing specific diets (keto, vegan, etc). These are people with a strong "why" behind meal planning.

One thing that helped me: listening to how other indie founders cracked this. The French podcast "Public SaaS Builders" has some great episodes on early traction tactics from bootstrapped founders. Worth checking out if you understand French or use auto-translate.

Keep shipping and talking to users. The first paying customer always feels impossible until it happens 💪

I was in almost the exact spot on my last project. Build went well, launch did nothing, and I realised most of what I was doing was broadcast.

The first paying users didn’t come from Product Hunt, directories or social posts. They came from a handful of 1:1 conversations with people who already felt the problem strongly. I’d reach out after seeing them talk about the issue somewhere, ask how they were handling it today, and just listen. When someone was clearly frustrated and already hacking together a workaround, showing them the product felt like help, not a pitch. Those were the people who converted.

Another big one for me was tightening the promise. When I talked about what the product did, people were interested. When I talked about one specific outcome in their day that would get easier, people were willing to try it. Same product, different framing.

It was slower than I wanted, but those early conversations shaped the positioning and onboarding way more than any launch ever did.

Maybe your existing audience usually isn’t your customer. A newsletter audience might like your content or your story, but that doesn’t mean they feel the problem strongly enough to pay for a solution. So low clicks don’t automatically mean MealThinker is bad.

Even after building, validation still matters. The people you talk to while figuring out the problem often end up becoming your first actual users. That early feedback loop matters way more than launches or directories.

Also, this doesn’t really feel like a Product Hunt kind of product. It feels more like a habit tool. Those usually start by being insanely useful for one very specific type of person, not “anyone who eats food”. Therefore, distribution is where you'll win.

Building is the fun part. Getting people to care is slow, awkward, and way less glamorous.

Wow, a 2k user food blog base is a huge leg up. Could you use your influence there to secure a partnership? Maybe a brand that reaches out to you for promotion on your blog

The newsletter open rate isn't the problem — 13% is solid. The issue is likely audience-product fit. Food blog readers want recipes, not necessarily an AI to plan their meals.

What worked for me: Instead of broadcasting to a list, I found 5-10 people actively complaining about the specific problem on Reddit/Twitter and DMed them directly. "Hey, saw your post about X — I built something that might help. Would you try it for free and give me honest feedback?"

Those 1:1 conversations converted way better than any launch blast. Plus the feedback shaped the product.

For meal planning specifically, I'd look at r/mealprep, r/EatCheapAndHealthy, or Facebook groups for busy parents. Find the people already manually solving the problem you're automating.

The first 10 users almost never come from marketing. They come from conversations.

How long has the product been out for? Success won't happen overnight. Spend a bit more time doing SEO & ASO, it'll help drive more and more traffic to your product. Don't overlook the effectiveness of localisation too.

Add your product to directories over the course of weeks/months, and be consistent with posting on social media, if only a few posts in a day.

Reach out to journalists and tell them about your product. Do the same with podcasters and see if you can get interviews in order to explain what your app is about and what problem it solves, about what your product does better than X or Y.

Reddit is also a great place to post. Find subreddits and people in general that need your product and reach out to them personally, get feedback. If you already have 2,000 potential interested users, post again to them and offer them some free trial in order to get genuine feedback that you can use to craft your product.

Also, it might be worth thinking about building in reverse in the future. Make a quick landing page and add an email 'waitlist' form and make a post on Twitter/X mentioning your upcoming product. If it gets traction, you have an early indicator that you're potentially onto something. It'll take you a day and you'll get quick feedback. Less time consuming than building a product you think is incredible but others may not.

You'll find a lot of people are in the same boat. Don't become demotivated. Show up every day and little by little you'll get more exposure and more users.

All the best,
Andy.

the "yelling into the void" part hits hard. been there.

one thing i learned the hard way - distribution channels need to be warmed up BEFORE the product is ready. not after. building an audience while building the product is 10x harder than building the product itself.

the 13% open rate on your newsletter is actually decent. the problem might be the list wasnt primed for this specific product. food blog readers might not be the same people who want an AI meal planner.

what if you found 10 people who actively complain about meal planning in communities (reddit, fb groups, etc) and just... asked them if theyd try it? not a launch blast. just 1:1 convos.

the first paying customers usually come from direct relationships, not broadcasts. at least thats what ive seen work.

I am on a similar path
I built this tool called cvcomp. It is a resume scanners but has JD based scan feature and in built editor, and everyone who tried it really loved the product.
As I am a solo marketer, I am running the Insta, Linkedin and YT, doing backlinks, preparing for product hunt launch and on other AI directories as well.
I have got just 4 paid users after a week of launch. So yeah its tyring but exciting

I’ve been in this exact spot. ~

It’s rough — especially once the build high wears off and you’re left staring at reality.

One thing that stood out to me: most of what you tried is broadcast. That usually works later, not when you’re trying to find the first few people willing to pay.

What helped me early on was flipping the goal from “get users” to “find one specific person with a sharp pain.” Not growth — relief.

A rough frame I use now:

First users come from conversations, not launches

They already have a workaround (spreadsheets, notes, pure chaos)

Paying is less about features and more about trust + timing

For something like this, I’d probably start with people already obsessed with food logistics — parents meal-prepping every week, people tracking macros, or folks actively trying to cut food waste. Narrow enough that the problem feels personal.

One concrete thing that worked for me: reach out 1:1 and ask how they handle this today. Don’t pitch. If they start complaining, you’re close. If they shrug, move on fast.

Also worth saying: zero paid users doesn’t mean zero value yet. Most of the time it just means the problem isn’t sharp enough for the audience you’re talking to.

Curious — who do you imagine would be genuinely annoyed if this disappeared tomorrow?

I'm currently going through this, spent months building an enterprise B2B app thinking I'll definitely get users but that wasn't the reality of it, marketing has become the hardest part

это интересная стратегия и очень понятная

The comments above nailed the distribution side - finding people mid-frustration and outcome-focused messaging. I want to add one more angle that might be the actual blocker.

The gap between "6 clicks from 2k subs" and "zero paid users" suggests this isn't just a traffic problem. Even if you fix distribution, you might hit the same wall: people sign up, look around, and bounce.

The question I'd ask: what's the shortest path from signup to feeling the value? With a meal planner, the magic moment isn't seeing the interface - it's getting tonight's dinner sorted in under 2 minutes without thinking.

If your onboarding asks new users to manually input their kitchen inventory, dietary preferences, and meal history before they get their first plan, you're asking them to do homework before the demo. That's where activation dies.

The pattern I've seen work: give them one high-value win immediately (even if it's generic), then progressively personalize as they use it. Example: "Here are 3 meals you can make with chicken, rice, and bell peppers. Got those? Great, here's tonight's plan." Then learn preferences from behavior, not forms.

Once someone gets value in the first session, the free → paid conversation becomes about "do I want this every week?" instead of "do I trust this enough to even try it?"

Thanks for posting, Justin. I'm at the stage just before product launch, and I'm kicking myself for starting the marketing efforts so late.

I decided to take a UGC approach and, having no budget, decided to go 100% AI video and voice. I'm seeing much more engagement with video than my text/screenshot posts previously.

I'm a long way from getting paying users from my efforts, but I'm in it for the long haul.

Good luck!

I’m in the building stage right now but that’s the part that feels scary. I’m starting to post while I build to start getting some eyes early on and hopefully make this step easier.

Cold-start is indeed very difficult. With one of my previous SaaS applications, by sending out 400 cold-start emails daily, I acquired 50 users in a week (but none were paid users). Later, I analyzed, and the problem might be: placing the CTA too low, which affected my conversion rate. However, I'm still experimenting.

2k → 6 clicks is a big signal. That usually means the email promise isn’t matching what people care about.
What was the core outcome you emphasized in the email?

Hey Justin!
The newsletter thing makes sense in theory but I think the issue is you're broadcasting to people who signed up for food content — not people who are actively frustrated right now.

I'm in a pretty similar spot (zero paying users on a validation tool I built). What actually shifted my thinking was going where people are mid-frustration instead of trying to redirect attention from somewhere else.

I searched Reddit for people complaining about the exact problem my tool solves. Found 71 threads about freelancers struggling with invoicing. Sounds like a goldmine, right? Except zero of those 71 mentioned wanting to pay. They complain, grab a free tool, and move on.

That 10-minute search saved me from building into a dead market. But when I found communities where people ARE spending money on the problem, the conversations were completely different.

For MealThinker — I'd look at threads where someone says "I meal prep every Sunday and I'm running out of ideas" or "I spend 45 minutes deciding what to cook." That frustration-in-the-moment (not food blogs) is where your first paying user probably lives.

Have you checked specific subreddits for people complaining about meal planning?

this resonates. 14 active merchants on my shopify app, $0 MRR. built the product, launched on the app store, did the thing. installs come — people leave before they see value.

biggest lesson so far: distribution and activation are coupled but activation comes first. if 4 out of 10 people who install leave the same day, spending more time on distribution just fills a leaky bucket faster.

the "resident consultant" approach someone mentioned here is spot on. on reddit i just answer questions about shopify costs and margins — not pushing anything, just being helpful with stuff i genuinely know about from building the product. that kind of presence compounds way slower than a product hunt launch but the people who find you through it actually trust you.

one thing that hit me: your 2k newsletter subscribers were interested in recipes, not SaaS. the intent mismatch is brutal. same energy as getting shopify store owners to install an app — they want to solve a problem, not try new software. the pitch has to start from their pain, not your feature list.

The channel list you've tried is visibility plays — they get you in front of people browsing, not people mid-frustration.

First paid customers almost always come from where people are actively complaining about the problem you solve. For meal planning:

• Subreddits: r/MealPrepSunday (1.5M+), r/EatCheapAndHealthy, r/cookingforbeginners
• Facebook Groups: Meal Prep + Budget Cooking groups tend to have very specific "ugh I'm so tired of planning" posts
• YouTube comments: Under popular meal prep videos, people ask the same questions over and over

The pattern: find someone mid-frustration, be genuinely helpful (not pitchy), and the first few will convert.

Also — 2,000 blog subs is a real asset. The 13% open rate isn't bad, but 6 clicks means the CTA didn't land. What did the email actually say?

I collected 450 places to promote a startup and get traffic and backlinks!!

I know it’s very challenging for a new founder to generate traffic and conduct marketing for a new startup while also developing a product.

Sometimes it can feel overwhelming and confusing.

I’ve collected a list of websites that receive good traffic, where you can promote your product and get strong visibility and backlinks to help your site rank better.
It’s not free because it takes a lot of time to research and compile.

As a student and part-time founder, this helps me a lot.

www.marketingpack.store