4
3 Comments

How I made first page of HN and earned 220+ stars

... on GitHub in just one day.

This short article is just a trial to analyse what happened and why, without giving any piece of advice.

Yesterday I wanted to create a post on HN and I did it but then it seemed to me I did something wrong and I deleted the post. When I recreated it again, I saw the message "Sorry, that story was previously submitted.". I wrote to moderators and they replied "The repost restriction lasts for 8 hours". Well, okay, not a problem.
Let's do it tomorrow.

Right before (or after?) I posted the link to my GitHub repo I saw this epic post https://www.indiehackers.com/product/reader-mode/-LwHtDRxHXMA9GpiSXWO and tried to figure out which title would be the best one. I noticed that the encouraging to some action would probably work better and name my post "Create your next SaaS with Python and ReactJS".

Suddenly, boom! - I had comments, point, stars on GitHub - I could hardly believe it happened!

I did my best result ever - #9 on HN - and then it started dropping at some point (right now the post has 93 points).
Now, I would like to understand, what was going on and why.

I'm asking this question because I already created open-source products (the same SaaS boilerplates) and posted info on HN but never gained such results. The maximal amount of point on HN I earned before was just... yes, 3! Against 64 today (Upd: 95 now). And it never led to so many stars on GitHub.

Okay, I think the reasons are:

  1. The title of the post was pretty "sexy" and intriguing (thanks Ryzal, again!) (until the moderators (?) changed it to boring "SaaS application boilerplate" what I think led to the dropping the post down.

  2. This product looks much better than all previous versions. I worked really hard on UI and design (I'm not designer at all) and should admit I'm proud of the result :)) (even there is still a lot of things to do :)

  3. I used ReactJS in this project for the front-end (previous version used Vue.js). Even although I still like Vue.js I should admit it's much less popular than ReactJS, may it makes the whole project to look a little bit more appealing.

HN stats is here: http://hnrankings.info/21818323/

That's it, for now, thanks for reading!

, Founder of Icon for SaaS Forge
SaaS Forge
on December 18, 2019
  1. 1

    Ok this is epic! So happy that the idea got validated very well. Massive congrats and keep up the good work! :D

    1. 1

      Thanks for your experience! What I forgot to mention, I never shared the link to my HN post (as you described in your article), I think it helped me a lot.

      1. 1

        No problem! And ah that's wonderful, another plus point! +1 :))

Trending on Indie Hackers
Stop Spamming Reddit for MRR. It’s Killing Your Brand (You need Claude Code for BuildInPublic instead) User Avatar 219 comments What happened after my AI contract tool post got 70+ comments User Avatar 213 comments $36K in 7 days: Why distribution beats product (early on) User Avatar 92 comments Where is your revenue quietly disappearing? User Avatar 87 comments We made Android 10x faster. Now, we’re doing it for the Web. 🚀 User Avatar 71 comments a16z says "these startups don't exist yet - it's your time to build." I've been building one. User Avatar 57 comments