2
4 Comments

I hit #15 on the Build Board yesterday. The result: 0 signups and 1 sales pitch.

Yesterday, I launched ReStay, the MoR-agnostic retention engine I've been coding since April.

To my absolute shock, it hit #15 on the Indie Hackers Build Board. I was thrilled. But in the spirit of building in public, here is the raw reality of my metrics today:

  • Traffic: A nice spike from the IH community.

  • Signups: Exactly 0.

  • Emails: 1 (from a founder who smoothly pivoted into pitching me their own SaaS; not that I mind πŸ˜…).

Honestly? I still see this as a massive win.

I’m a solo, technical founder, and doing sales/marketing is entirely out of my comfort zone. But that one post and email conversation proved my core hypothesis: The biggest pain point isn't just churn. It's founders terrified of losing their historical data if they switch from Stripe to Paddle or Dodo Payments.

My next step is completely ignoring standard marketing. Instead, I'm going to start doing sniper-focused outreach to founders who are actively migrating billing platforms to see if I can solve their exact data continuity headache.

If you have ever launched on IH and got crickets on day two, how did you pivot to finding your first true Ideal Customer Profile?

posted toAvatar for product ReStay
ReStay
  1. 2
    The 0 signups / 1 pitch ratio is familiar territory β€” I launched a small free tool two weeks ago (an EVM address verifier for crypto sends), got a little traffic from X and Reddit, and the honest result was a handful of real checks and zero "this is my ICP" moments. Two things that actually worked for me: (1) I stopped pitching the tool and started answering questions where the pain shows up (r/Base, r/USDC), and my first real users came from comments where I explained the problem first and linked the tool after; (2) I put my real launch numbers on the product page itself β€” that honesty did more for trust than any landing copy I'd written. One note on your sniper outreach: the founder who pitched you their own SaaS might be worth keeping on the list. People actively migrating billing are exactly the people who know other people doing the same thing.
  2. 1
    The zero signups are actually less interesting than the one conversation that changed your hypothesis. I’d be careful not to treat that single migration pain as the ICP yet β€” curious whether you’re going to test it across several founders actively switching MoRs before narrowing ReStay around it.
    1. 1

      I did get more valuable feedback and neutral reception from many other folks in the last 24 hours. Specially from r/SaaS. Thanks.

      1. 1
        That makes sense. It sounds like the broader feedback is giving you a better base to work from before narrowing the direction.