15
10 Comments

Meet the new community! ʕ•́ᴥ•̀ʔっ♡

Hey! My name is Alex and I enjoy talking online very much.
There are plenty of places on the web to hang out with makers and startup folks.
But I do not like any of those.

After years of entrepreneurship, I earned that sense which helps me to realize what I dislike about this or that. And how it should work to satisfy me.

It turned out none of the existing ways of talking online satisfy me. Let be specific and see what is wrong with the existing online communities:

What I dislike in Reddit.
The Reddit community is toxic.
I can not just hop in when I got something cool or just want to babble. I also can not promote my own stuff. I understand that using public channels as private twitter turns any space into a junkyard. But I do not like such a hardcore way of moderation Reddit gives. I feel like a stranger there.
There must be some kind of compromise and I think I found it.

What I dislike in Indie Hackers.
I LOVE the community! IH gave so much fun, insights, friends, ideas, feedback, and support. I even started regular offline IH meetups to get deeper into the community.
But there is a problem with this website: it is the Reddit-style temporary feed board. The new topics will be forgotten after 24 hours. The discussions are designed to die.
Why? This is so unfair. What if I got something new to add on the next day? Or in 3 days? Or in 3 months?
I believe that a discussion should be able to last forever. By gaining meat, threads become more and more meaningful.

What I dislike on Facebook.
Facebook insanely drains my attention. I'm very sensitive to these red indicators and notifications. I do not want to consume content that I'm forced to consume.
I do not like the way Facebook does their business and as a part of my protest, I do not spend time there. Just no.

What I dislike in instant messengers.
An average discussion in messenger lasts for a few minutes. This is just not enough time to engage enough people and get various and deep answers.
Besides, a thread in messager is hardly searchable and not indexable by search engines (Google). Therefore, when you answer in Telegram, your reply will be seen by a couple of folks, when you make an answer in a website, your reply will be seen by hundreds of people. This gives you additional motivation to craft greater answers.

What I dislike in Quora.
People visit Quora for link-building or promotion, but not for talking. Meh.

What I dislike in Hacker News.
It is just not for everybody. They have their own community with own strict rules, tradition, and history. I just don't get it.
And yeah, HN is still the feed type board, just like Reddit and IH.

Thus, I felt like I need to build my own place to talk with makers, geeks, designers and startup folks.

So I made this: https://broadwise.org

It is an old school online forum flavored with modern technologies (kudos to Discourse).
We have dozens of categories to talk about including tech, news, marketing, personal growth, sales, SMM, e-sports many more. Such a structured form of forum is designed to host meaningful discussions full of insights and various opinions that keep coming eternally.

I believe people should be able to promote their blogs and products. Indie Hackers taught us that is OK to show off what you did and there is nothing embarrassing in this. Broadwise.org adopts this tolerant approach.
Thus, you can create a thread dedicated to your blog or product and do some activity in it: invite people to discuss the latest blog or engage the public with a cool poll about your new product feature. You will get attention and people will get fun.

So welcome guys! Let's make a big warm, beginners friendly, full of thoughtful discussions which will bring fun and help to us for many years.
I believe it is gonna be an awesome journey!

Project link: https://broadwise.org

posted to Icon for group Community Building
Community Building
on April 22, 2020
  1. 2

    Hey @alexanderisora. I totally agree with you about those modern online communities. I will join Broadwise. But how will you manage when it hits more and more threads? I think IH and Reddit have their points on broadcasting new contents.

    And btw can you share more about how you built an oldschool forum like Broadwise. I want to build one for my book-reading community. I’m also a nocoder.
    Thanks!

    1. 2

      I will join Broadwise.

      high-five.gif

      But how will you manage when it hits more and more threads? I think IH and Reddit have their points on broadcasting new contents.

      I'm pretty sure the multi-level category structure can handle hundreds of topics :)

      And btw can you share more about how you built an oldschool forum like Broadwise. I want to build one for my book-reading community. I’m also a nocoder.

      It is a great idea, thanks for this! I will create a step-by-step guide on how to launch your own online community without any coding.

  2. 2

    Really Bright idea to re-invent oldschool forums!

    The article is nice, giving a quick pic on the problems with modern community platforms (FB, Twitter, etc.) Nowdays they became a huge junkyards and are used mostly for spamming, selling or promoting something, not for discussing... Which is SAD. Like almost every aspect of modern life, like culture, offline social communication (not without a help of COVID-19 hysteria), family celebrations and "tea meetings"... the chat and social platforms degrade seriously.

    I love Ind ie Hackers platform. The only weak point IH has, is that you can`t find anything after 24 hours. Although almost every indie-hacker / startaper has a link to IH profile in their Bio, so you can visit their profile and read all their posts in a flow.

    Gratz @alexanderisora

    1. 2

      Thanks for the warm words man!

      I miss the old days when people used websites to actually talk, not to sell. But I suppose self-promo is a part of today's online communities. We should just learn how to divide it.

      IH did it just perfectly. I want to find the balance on Broadwise too. It is goal #1.

      Although almost every indie-hacker / startaper has a link to IH profile in their Bio, so you can visit their profile and read all their posts in a flow.

      Although technically it is possible to find an answer, I do not like the one-direction flows (Personal pain: the infinite scroll. God, why?). It is searchable.
      But what I dislike in the Reddit-style boards is that it wants you to dive into today's flow. It is easy to turn off your brain and get lost in a unified "good for everybody" flow served for you by a smart algorithm.

      But the lifespan of a piece of information becomes very small. This dramatically decreases the value of discussions.

  3. 1

    Why dont you have the way to sign up with just login? I usually dont like to give permissions to any of my accounts to sign up. Signed up anyway.

    1. 2

      Hey Natalie! Welcome on board! 🤠

      Great question!
      I have experience building online communities in the past. It turns out if you allow signing up with login your community will be overwhelmed with spam and meaningless posts. This will drain a few hours per day for moderation and the website will still look spammy and low quality.

      So I decided to set up this barrier 👾

Trending on Indie Hackers
I built something that helps founders turn user clicks into real change 🌱✨ User Avatar 32 comments I built a text-to-video AI in 30 days. User Avatar 31 comments You don't need to write the same thing again User Avatar 29 comments I built an Image-to-3D SaaS using Tencent's Hunyuan 3D AI User Avatar 25 comments The Era of Malleable SaaS: Is This the End of "Opinionated Software"? User Avatar 17 comments Let’s Talk: What’s Missing in Today’s App Builders? User Avatar 17 comments