Home
Starting Up
Case Studies DB
Products
Ideas DB
Vibe Coding Tools
Subscribe to IH+
Starting Up
Case Studies
Ideas DB
Products DB
Join
37
Likes
0
Bookmarks
26
Comments
Report
What would you put on your validation checklist before starting a new business?
by
Channing Allen
If you decided to start a new business today:
What are the top things you'd put on your validation checklist?
What data, if any, would you be basing this approach on (e.g. past business experience, a credible book/blog/study, raw intuition, etc.)?
Trending on Indie Hackers
Never hire an SEO Agency for your Saas Startup
100 comments
I shipped a productivity SaaS in 30 days as a solo dev — here's what AI actually changed (and what it didn't)
79 comments
A simple way to keep AI automations from making bad decisions
67 comments
“This contract looked normal - but could cost millions”
54 comments
👉 The most expensive contract mistakes don’t feel risky
41 comments
Are indie makers actually bad customers?
36 comments
Those are the basics imo. One for each startup failure I've had.
I'd also add forget the notion of a blanket good idea. There is only only such thing as a good idea for a specific individual at a specific time.
Every individual has a math equation with bespoke variables (their specific attributes and goals) which output the perfect idea for them to work on a specific time. So focus on your equation.
What are your goals? What are your strengths? What are your weaknesses?
And build your idea from that.
This is an amazing answer and list.
Cheers Ian
I really like the simplicity of this list. Third point is brilliant because it also informs what your MVP needs to be.
Appreciated. Thank you. It works for me
Should be framed :D
The first thing would be: can I make $1,000 within 2-3 months?
The second thing would be: can I grow that 20%+ / month over the next few months?
I'm always anxious about whether I'm spending my time on the right thing. When I was focused on growing subscribers or building products, I never really felt confident I was spending my time wisely. But being able to tie effort to revenue growth is validating and makes me more focused.
For context I'm trying to grow a side project to $10K MRR. For those with different goals that advice may not apply
How often will I use it myself?
Who are the first 99 clients?
Can a functional MVP be ready in one month?
I feel like the better question is "what are you lessons learned from past startups":
https://www.indiehackers.com/post/what-was-the-lesson-from-the-ghost-of-startup-past-95708ccc9f
Michel.
Many good comments already, and I would include some of them. I would also definitely include the following:
If you can't sell it, you don't have a business, you have a hobby. Also I have learned that the distance between "I think someone might pay for this eventually" is far far away from actually making a sale.
What I’ve promised myself to never do again is to pick a product that both needs to cater B2B AND B2C to be successful. Very hard! Especially to focus on which to give more attention, marketing etc
I have worked in three hardware startups and in everyone the biggest validation for us was going through Indiegogo - if there is a demand than we can scale it. But it took a few month preparations and working with advisers from Indie.
Hey!
Here I have a great checklist to Launch a Successful e-Commerce Website: https://dinarys.com/blog/how-to-launch -successful-ecommerce-website-the-ultimate-checklist
Here the main points from checklist:
All items are based on experience and international practices. Of course, it all depends on your business goals and budget.
I'm a big believer in having a huge validation checklist.
It's well-known that constraints breed creativity, but it's still unintuitive. Many believe that having a large number of items on their checklist will make it harder to settle on a good idea. Au contraire, those constraints will serve as prompts to get you thinking more creatively. You'll end up developing more great ideas as a result, not fewer. My checklist has something like 75 items on it.
If I wanted to start another bootstrapped and profitable indie hacker business, my top questions would be:
Hi @csallen,
Great points!
If you do not mind, can you share the whole checklist for inspiration? I understand that a lot will be dependant on your personal preferences but I believe it could be helpful for others.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1e-pmkZCM96V_3FhwYFK5ubY8l52YNk9j4i25HWt6oyY/edit#heading=h.eqrnmfrqlu9c
Thanks! 👌
Do people use/need it? -> If yes, you'll figure out what exactly they need. The market (if there is one) will always pull you in the direction it needs you to be.
User Research/Interviews and based on my experience (scratching my own itch).
I wouldn't use a validation checklist.
Based on what I've read and heard from too many investors, I believe using a checklist is the surest way to miss the very best opportunities.
I'm skeptical of validation skeptics. 😝 Invariably they're using a validation checklist of their own, but are weirdly adamant about not writing it down or analyzing it in any way.
For example, how is it possible to say yes or no to an investment opportunity without any sort of criteria? If you have criteria, that's a checklist. Even if your only criterion is "my intuition," fine, you still have a checklist, and it has a single questionable item on it.
I'm also skeptical of investors who claim to know how to identify the very best opportunities at the pre-idea phase. I don't think anyone knows how to do that, as the very best ideas are (by definition) rare outliers whose success can only be predicted in hindsight, and thus require luckily being in the right place at the right time with the right mindset. Otherwise, the ideas would be formulaic and obvious, in which case everyone would know about them, in which case they'd (by definition) be average ideas instead of great ideas, and everything would depend on execution.
Even then, when people make proclamations of this sort, they still have a checklist. It usually includes items like (a) emerging market or nascent trend that's small but growing, (b) believing in something strongly that nobody else believes in, (c) having an idea that looks like a toy and nobody else takes seriously, etc, etc.
I appreciate that... with skepticism! 😝
Checklists are binary. Other heuristics aren't necessarily. I prefer models where inputs interact with each other, instead of flat a list of hard requirements or a list of checks to tally. I also lean towards betting on an extreme strength (or set of complimentary strengths) rather than eliminating every option with clear weaknesses.
That make sense. I don't usually treat my checklists as a list of hard requirements. Rather, I like to think of them as memory aids, both for ensuring I avoid doing things that are obviously bad and ensuring I spot opportunities that are obviously good.
Ah, that makes way more sense! I had a completely different image in mind, more like a government application for something.