March 2, 2020

Removed the free version of the plugin

Ferenc Forgacs @feriforgacs

I launched the free version of Story View back in September and my main goal with it was to reach a wider audience of potential customers. My hypothesis was that it would be much easier to sell the pro license of the plugin to those who already used and liked the free version of it. It looks like I was wrong.

The free version got 60 downloads with zero upgrades. I didn't send sales emails to those who downloaded the free version. There was an automated follow-up email a week after someone made the download. Only one person sent a response to that and it was about a download issue.

The UI of the free version contained several links that pointed to the PRO version of the plugin and I also highlighted what are the features that are only available for PRO users. It looks like this wasn't enough to convince anyone to make an upgrade.
Maybe the limitations in the free version weren't enough, maybe they didn't want to use it after they give it a try. I don't know.

We'll see what happens now that only the PRO version is available.

  1. 2

    Follow up and let us know how it goes!

  2. 2

    My opinion on free stuff is that you use it to generate leads. If you create something free that is directly relevant to the audience you eventually want to sell something to, it's a good way to show them you can provide value.

    I use free things as lead magnets for my product. My product is a plugin for Adobe Illustrator that quickly exports and sorts logo files. It is $99. There is no free version of my product, but I do give away a tutorial that shows how to export logos quickly from Illustrator (using built-in methods).

    Customers can download that for free and see that I know what I'm talking about. They can also compare that process to what I am offering for a cost.

    I know they are likely interested in my product if they download the tutorial, but I don't have to worry about them getting upset when I suddenly try to charge them because the freebie is an entirely separate offering from the product.

    1. 1

      I had the same intention by providing a free version of the plugin but I'm afraid that the free version was too "powerful" or the PRO features don't worth the price. Or these two together. Or something else I'm not thinking about :D

      I think my target audience is huge (WordPress users) but I'm afraid that most of them are looking for free solutions as the base platform is free as well and there are free alternatives for almost anything. This makes me think that maybe this is not the right space for me if I want to make a living from my products.

  3. 2

    I always used the freemium model for my plugins and it works very well. Clearly it has its downside. When a freemium product doesn't convert it can be for many reasons but it's not a fault of this business model.
    You said "maybe they didn't want to use it after they give it a try. I don't know." You really should investigate it! I use Freemius to get stats about my free users and to understand the reasons of uninstall and get also their emails.
    Said that I also chose to give a try to only-premium model for my latest plugin However I started from a different need: in my case I wanted to avoid supporting a free plugin, which is a cost I'm not happy to pay.
    I launched the plugin 1 month ago and got only 1 sale, the problem of premium-only is you need to market your product and I'm not good at it :-\ I'm working on SEO but it requires time to work properly.

    1. 1

      I'm sure I didn't do everything right :D as this was the first time I used this business model and I'm also sure it works just fine when you know how to use it properly, I saw lots of great examples.
      You are right that I should find the reason why no one switched to the premium version. The worst-case scenario is nobody will tell anything to me, but that won't make my situation worse.

      1. 2

        Consider a simple but very true fact: people doesn't tell you anything until you asked them for a feedback. Another cool feature of Freemius is they automatically send an email to users who uninstall a plugin asking why they uninstalled. Few people answer but someone sent me valid feedbacks so I was able to understand some aspect of my plugins that weren't working well.

        1. 1

          Very true.
          I have another product (a Shopify app) where I send an email to the customers right after they install, uninstall the app. No one sent a response yet, but I hope one they somebody will send me some valuable feedback :)
          I'll take a look at Freemius as well as now I'm handling the plugin update, hosting, upgrade process mostly by myself.
          Thank you for your comments.

          1. 2

            I strongly recommend Freemius! They handle the plugin updates plus some useful marketing actions like cart recovery, survey after plugin deactivation, beta programs, trials and many more nice things.

  4. 1

    I had a similiar situation in my project. I had a PRO button everywhere, and no one would even click it (I tracked). I think people don't repect when something is for free and have a PRO version.

    1. 2

      I displayed the "notification" about the pro version where it was reasonable. For example where I made some limitations in the plugin. This means that there were about 5 to 7 different locations where the users of the free version saw it. I didn't want to annoy them but maybe I had to try more ways to convert them to paying customers.

Today's Top Milestones
  • Shut Down
    Golazo was born a few years ago but since I have no enough time to work on it, I decided to shut down the project. Also, I need to integrate it to the
  • Shut Down
    Since I have no enough time to work on it, I decided to shut down the project. Also, Apple is strict about rejecting apps that don't provide minimum f
  • Launched on PH!
    I decided to launch on PH today. I didn't expect much as Show HN was a failure and didn't make it to the proper show hn page. But with PH, it is total
  • Switched to Paddle for subscriptions and payments
    I just figured that I have been forgetting to write some updates every now and then here, and I am not receiving reminders about it even though they a
  • Ready for Beta Launch
    I wasted the last 2 weeks thinking that I had to wait for Pocket to review the app, but apparently, I don't have to 😁 So I'm just fine-tuning a few t
  • Now Push secured our first paying 33 customers
    Just under a week into our general release, we have closed the week off with (at the time of writing) 33 customers, this means we have just under 500
  • Created MKM Tracks
    Created the Wealth, Growth and Entrepreneurs tracks. This will allow to manage member subscription lists to send emails every few days with specific i
  • Page Insight Got indexed by Google search
    3 days back, I submitted page Insight to the Google search console and today it finally appeared on Google search. Hopefully it is the start of my SEO
  • MVP Launch
    Unlike many of my past creations, I wanted to launch as fast as possible to gauge interest from the community. Being an information-drive